But the Imperial Japanese army in 1941 was battle-hardened—but not yet worn down—by the China War.
It’s just a really bad idea, as Germany can attest.
This became painfully obvious to Hitler during the 1941–42 Battle of Moscow, when the Red Army’s well-trained and well-equipped Siberian divisions reinforced the battered Soviet armies defending Moscow. Stalin suffered a nervous breakdown when Germany, with whom Russia had a nonaggression pact, launched its massive Barbarossa surprise attack. So, would Hitler still have declared war on the U.S. four days after the attack on Pearl Harbor had the Japanese been averted by detection? Exactly 70 years ago Japan hit Pearl Harbor with one of the most stunning surprise attacks in history.
Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan (whom the Nazis classified as honorary Aryans) were loose allies at best. It would have enjoyed powerful air and naval support. The Soviet Union could lose Vladivostok (even though much American Lend-Lease came through that port), but Moscow was a different matter. DSmith.
If Japan didn't bomb Pearl Harbor, then World War II wouldn't have happened and tons of lives wouldn't have been lost. By the time the B-29 bomber soared over Hiroshima and deployed the first-ever atomic bomb, Japan’s military seemed to be facing an imminent defeat.
What most Americans forget is that it was not only Pearl Harbor that Japan attacked on December 7, 1941. We rely on readers like you to uphold a free press. By clicking “I agree” below, you consent to the use by us and our third-party partners of cookies and data gathered from your use of our platforms. Spared from battle with the Americans, the Imperial Navy could have employed naval gunfire and its elite, long-range Zero fighter squadrons to ensure air superiority for a drive on the vital port of Vladivostok.As it bravely but ineptly demonstrated against the Finns and Germans, the Red Army in 1941 had been devastated by Stalin’s purges. One of the great what-ifs of the Second World War is what would have happened if Japan had attacked the Soviet Union in 1941, when the Soviet Union seemed at defeat’s door as the German panzers drove deep into Russia.
The real action was a continent away, in Moscow. Why Didn’t Japan Finish Job? At the least, a Russo-Japanese war would have diverted Soviet resources away from Germany and thus prolonged the European war, though perhaps America would have found Japan less difficult to subdue. Given a choice between retaining Moscow or Vladivostok, Stalin would have prioritized defending the Soviet capital, so Japan might have taken Vladivostok and the Siberian coast without too much effort.
The attack on Pearl Harbor in December gave Roosevelt all the ammunition he needed. First, if the Battle of Moscow was one of the turning points of World War II, then would Japan pinning down the Siberian reinforcements have crippled the Soviet counteroffensive?
By that time, Japan may have locked in part—or all—of its gains in the Far East. Had Japan declared war on the Soviet Union in 1941, the East might have been Red, as the But then what? Yet many of the Soviet armies at Moscow were hastily thrown together, inexperienced, poorly led and still struggling to regain their balance from the German onslaught.
Perhaps the American entry into the war would have been delayed long enough for the Germans to be able to concentrate their forces against Russia, possibly changing the outcome of the war.
The Japanese could have heavily augmented their oil needs with reserves in said countries. Japan knew that American industrial centers could be converted into the production of war materiel. The traditional narrative is that in mid-1941, Japanese leaders were split between the What would have if Japan had struck north after all, attacking Russia from the east while Germany relentlessly advanced from the west? America and Britain also fought World War II in Europe and Asia.In contrast, the Soviet Union could concentrate its forces against Germany, thanks to a 1941 neutrality pact with its long-time rival Japan. Pearl Harbor was paramount to the US becoming involved in World War 2. Militarily, the outcome of a 1941 Russo-Japanese war would have been far from certain. At the time Japan was already one of the Axis powers, linked with Italy and Germany . 1 9. If Japan did not bomb pearl harbor, let us put it this way. Consider this: if Japan had not attacked Pearl Harbor, would isolationist America would have declared war on Japan? Russia had been defeated in the Russo-Japanese War of 1904–5, and during its intervention in the Russian Civil War, Japanese troops had advanced all the way to Lake Baikal.
Would it have changed the course of World War II?
See our And it wasn’t like the attack on Pearl Harbor was the first stage in a … It seems likely the Soviet counteroffensive would have thrown back Hitler’s armies without the Siberians, but would have inflicted less damage. Without the attack, the war would have been hugely different. Time would have been on its side.
The Red Army suffered four million casualties in 1941; it had enough problems attempting to build new divisions and control the ones it already had in western Russia, without having to deal with a Siberian front.The Russo-German War was a war of annihilation. Peace was not possible until one side or the other was conquered. (Recommended: 5 Ways Japan Could Have Won World War II) On the other hand, Japan was not one of Germany’s satellite armies on the Eastern front. 1 2.
The German armies in front of Moscow were depleted, exhausted, unsupplied and freezing. And if Japan had attacked Russia, which certainly would have compelled the Western powers to tighten their embargo, how would the Japanese economy have fared?
Garrison vast Siberia while still attempting to subdue the vast population of China?
If so, the real impact might have been in 1942. Like most great what-if questions, the answer depends on the assumptions you make. Italy and Romania were like the seven dwarves to the Aryan Snow White, and the Red Army smashed them with ease. Japan could have thrown all naval assets at the British and Dutch in Burma, India, and Indonesia, as well as Australia.